West Read Ever, Week 3

Those among you with an eye for detail might notice there was no post for WRE week 2. Yup. When I planned this I didn’t anticipate that work would suddenly become much more intense. I won’t pretend that my job is always draining, but it has been lately. I’ve been going home and finding that I simply don’t have the bandwidth even for comics. Something that has become apparent very quickly is that I need to allocate my resources better. Frankly though, I would rather just not make a post than have one where I go “my bad” and give my excuses (valid of otherwise), so I did.

This week I did make a point of creating some reading time. The numbers came up slightly!

Slightly is good, we’re still at the beginning of this and we’re going to pick up the pace (not a guarantee).

So what did I read this week? Let’s start with a confession: I love buying comic grab bags. An Ollie’s recently opened in my town, and they often have grab bags. So I’ve amassed a whole pile of a few hundred random comics that I only want a few dozen of, but I want to read a lot of them before passing them on. Will they all “count” for the purposes of this reading challenge? I don’t know yet, it doesn’t seem particularly… fair? to count seven issues of Batman that I didn’t select, they just happened to come in grab bags. I guess I imagine this needing to have purpose. At the end of the day though, does it even matter as long as I’m reading? That’s the gospel I preach when I’m trying to validate kids reading comics, why am I hesitant to extend that to myself? Hmm…

This week I read five random issues of The Tick that came out of Ollie’s comic grab bags. I love The Tick, although said love has ebbed and flowed over the years largely due to the comics not being terribly easy to get. I have a whole diatribe about comic markets and distribution that I could insert here, but I’m not going to. Suffice it to say that I don’t pick up enough issues of The Tick, because any time I do it’s like saying hello to an old friend. The Tick doesn’t ask much of the reader. The continuity has never been that deep, and neither have the characters. But that’s the strength and beauty of The Tick. To inhabit his world for twenty-odd pages, all you need is the ability to chuckle at the absurd. There’s a cozy simplicity to that, and it was good to say hello to him again. I should do it more often.

My other big read for the week was Galaxy: The Prettiest Star by Jadzia Axelrod and Jess Taylor. I heard the good press about this one, but hadn’t paid much more attention. Recently the sequel (As The World Falls Down) came out and Axelrod shared a page on Bluesky that in one panel showed me she perfectly understands Superman–not an easy thing, as any comic reader can tell you.

You see that bottom-left panel? The most powerful man in the world, known throughout time and space, and he smiles and introduces himself because it’s polite and that’s how his parents raised him. *chef’s kiss* If Axelrod can get Superman so easily, I reasoned, I need to see what else she can do. I want to read this book, but it’s the second and I should read the first one, right?

I finished The Prettiest Star last night, and I’m still processing it. What I can tell you is that I read something REALLY good. Amazing even. It broke my heart and put it back together several times. I’ll be recommending this to a lot of people. I wish comics like this had been available when I was growing up, but I’m glad they’re here now and I can’t wait until my kid is old enough to handle it. We’re going to have so many good talks.

Watch this space, I’m probably going to be gushing about As The World Falls Down next week.

-Luke

West Read Ever, week 1

I started WRE on May 1st. I’m going to be honest, I didn’t hit it hard out of the gate like I hoped to. But this has been a strange week and I know I can easily pick up the numbers going forward. Apparently, and this is something I hadn’t really digested, I’ve become a person who needs to make time for reading or it just doesn’t happen. This is new for me, as I’ve spent most of my life being the person who puts reading first–to the point that it’s sometimes been an issue for me!

So let’s see what I managed to tackle…

Back in April I was going on vacation and picked up the Collected Comics edition of Superman/Batman for road trip reading. It has the first two arcs of the 2003 Superman/Batman series, with Jeph Loeb doing the writing. Ed McGuinness does the art on the first arc, Michael Turner on the second. That’s a hell of a style whiplash!

That first arc, Public Enemies, reactivated the part of my brain that loves McGuinness’ art style. He does superheroes like they’re Masters of the Universe characters, and it shouldn’t work to have so many characters be this buff but it totally does. I was reminded that action figures were made based on the story, and it looks like they’re still fairly easy to find and affordable. I could, in theory, build up a nice little DC collection in this style… for those who know me, I’m heading down an extremely dangerous path here!

Anywho, looking up the figures reminded me that McGuinness was also on the fourth Superman/Batman arc, which I’d never read, and brings me to Superman/Batman: Vengeance. You may have noticed that I skipped over the third arc entirely, which has its ups and downs. It does get referenced, but it’s not imperative that one reads it. Vengeance references Public Enemies and Supergirl (the second arc) FAR more, directly following up on plot threads in those. It also follows up on the then-recent Emperor Joker story. That seems like a weird pull to me because we end up with a story that is self-contained for anyone following this one book until it turns out to be a direct sequel to a multi-part Superman story that (as we’re reminded in-story!) hadn’t been collected at that point. I know, I know, crossovers and continuity and all that, I’m a nerd and I love it, but it felt something like watching a show and then halfway through the season finding out that everything actually leads to wrapping up a plot from a spinoff show. Or maybe like watching the spinoff and it wraps up something from the main? I’m starting to confuse myself so I’m going to move on. You either get what I’m saying here or you don’t.

The book was good though! Loeb and McGuinness make a fun team, and it was a hoot to see all these existing and new alternate universe characters–which manages to include the Avengers! I started out liking that aspect, but as the story really got moving it felt awkward and out of place. Instead of the Avengers pastiche we should have gotten even more alternate reality DC characters, since that was the whole theme of the thing.

It wasn’t a quick read, given alternating character perspectives and alternate universes and so on. That was a very good thing because it was so much fun to look at. A case where it really feels like art and writing achieve a synergy and both are saying “slow down and take it all in”.

I’m going to level with you: I have ALWAYS liked the “armored” Daredevil costume. Even when it wasn’t cool to like it, I had the whole Fall From Grace arc and read it until it fell apart. One of the nicer things about nerd culture taking over and the march of time and catering to nostalgia is that if you give something reviled for being “uncool” long enough, the people who liked it will be numerous enough to justify doing more of it, and here we are!

This book isn’t trying to do anything new, not that I can see. I get the feeling Chichester just never got the chance to do a straight “New Daredevil” Jack Batlin adventure and really wanted to, so he did. He starts out placing the story seemingly days after the end of Fall From Grace. We’re reminded multiple times that DD’s suit is “bio-mimetic” and thus has a lot of cool features that help it stand up to the punishment it takes way better than his traditional costume. It gives him an edge that he doesn’t normally possess. I have a personal take that most superheroes should have a whole wardrobe of costumes so they can dress appropriately to fight the villain of the story, so I’m totally here for “sometimes Daredevil should have armor”. A running gag of the story is that other characters call it “armor” but DD never does. Well guess what Matt-Jack, it’s in the name of the story so you lose.

I initially found the story confusing. Matt-Jack goes to Melvin Potter, former supervillain and current superhero tailor (nice work if you can get it) to repair his suit. Then just a few pages later he’s suddenly in the suit, and I thought I’d missed something because it doesn’t feel like enough time has passed. At the end of the first issue DD stumbles right onto the major villain of the arc, but I guess he just forgets and leaves because in issue 2 he needs Spider-Man to get info he already knows so he can find the same villain. I did a lot of confused flipping! But once the comic settles into its groove I had a lot of fun with it. I’m not familiar with Netho Diaz, but I really enjoyed the art here. It really does feel like a 90s book, a “lost adventure” of sorts. I definitely recommend treating yourself. I don’t think it’s strictly necessary to read Fall From Grace to follow it, but that’s tough to say since I know that story so well (and I would recommend it regardless!).

That’s it for this week. Let’s see what I can get up to for next week.

-Luke

West Read Ever

William Bruce West and I weren’t close. It would probably be more correct to call us “acquaintances” than “friends”. But the man had presence, and adult friendships are weird in the online/social media age. He was an oversized part of my life just through being in it at all. After his stroke I was mentally filing away things to chat with him about, or that I wanted to get his take on. I still find myself doing that here and there. I miss him a lot.

In February of 2025 Will gave himself a reading challenge on his blog, West Week Ever. He updated it weekly, trying to reach his modest goals by the end of the year.

Continue reading

Starting Over

I’m not sure where this is going to end up, but I’m going to start it here. I’ve deleted the handful of old posts and I’m figuring out how this thing is supposed to work. We’ll see how well I manage it. -Luke